Olympic spirit idyllic pretension?

In light of the Tibetan escalation, the European Union is considering stepping up against China – EU Foreign Commissioner Benita Ferrero-Waldner mentioned a possible boycott of the Olympic Games in Peking 2008. According to Ferrero-Waldner, all of us, especially Western corporations working in China, do have responsibilities in ensuring China respects human rights. The respecting of human rights and the concept of freedom of opinion and media are the underlying principles of international understanding and thereby of the Olympiad – since Ferrero-Waldner does not perceive these conditions to be present in China, she considers the possible boycott to be legitimate. China’s actions in the following weeks will be monitored and will lead to a decision about the EU’s role in this year’s games.  

In this article, I will not attempt to judge on China’s actions in regard to human rights. It could certainly be argued that their measures are most brute, violent and contradictory to the Olympic spirit. However, let us consider the role of the Olympic Games. The Olympiad gives the world an almost unique opportunity to be in unison for a short period of time, regardless of wars and cruelties happening simultaneously. One could argue that the Olympics are therefore anyway not much more than a pretension of an idyllic, non-existent situation. We should, however, not forget that it is mainly politicians who are responsible for conflicts; people in the world are, essentially, all equal in their desires. It is Tibet and China that are in disagreement, not individual Tibetans and Chinese. In this sense, people themselves are much closer to the Olympic spirit of co-existence and unity than are politicians. In inflicting the current political situation on what has belonged to people so far, Ferrero-Waldner trivializes the concept of the Olympic Games. We should not give away this perhaps last event independent of cruelties happening. It is an icon of hope that one day; the world will be able to work together jointly. 

On a more practical level, I would like to suggest that with today’s huge global problems, climate change being only one of them, we must start to collaborate if we do not want to face our own extinction. Events such as the Olympics are crucial in fostering international understanding. Progress can only be made if discussion and co-operation are present; a boycott eliminates these vital processes.

Andrea D. Mihic (Switzerland, AC07-09)

– United World College Student Magazine –


5 thoughts on “Olympic spirit idyllic pretension?

  1. i agree, to a certain extent, with your opinion about the olympics and the merits of having it.However, with regard to other points you have made, i would like to differ on the basis of the fact that olympic is symbolic, not only of sports ideals but also political ideals like freedom and justice.By accepting china as an olympic host, even with the knowledge of their past history on people’s basic rights,this is an injustice in making.Boycott is a passive resistance through which we are seeking for justice.For tibetans, it is THE opprtunity ..What else do you think we can do given teh increasing international dependence on china in this critical time.
    Ps; views expressed here is from a tibetan side..criticism welcomed.

  2. I totally agree with you andreamihic . We all have to collaborate to solve major problems. My opinion is that we won’t achieve anything through Olympics boykott. Even the Dalai Lama dissuaded from doing so, for the only sustainble weapons are nonviolence and honesty.
    I believe we should give a chance to China.

  3. I disagree with the choice of China as host country of the Olympic Games. Indirectly, the committee organizer has blood on hands. Many workers have already died on construction sites, and others will still die. Because lives in china seems less important than the money saved through a security virtually non-existent.
    However, I agree with Andrea, a boycott would not be constructive.

Tell us what you think!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s